New York Pizza Pub


  • New York Pizza Pub
  • 2217 S. Croatan Hwy
  • Nags Head, NC
  • (252)-441-2660

New York Pizza Pub is one of the largest restaurants on the beach, and the ample space helps promote a feeling of non-cluttered, relaxed dining. We also added an outdoor deck where it’s perfect for take-out dining with your dog or for sipping on a refreshment as your table is being prepared. But the biggest calling card is our large and fine-tuned menu that combines truly authentic Italian dishes, made from scratch and with Grandma’s recipes, along with imaginative local seafood, salads and burgers. Locals will tell you that we serve the best steak on the beach! Our hand-tossed New York-style pizza ranks at the top of everyone’s list, of course, including our gluten-free ones! And we will promise you that your service will be the friendliest you’ve ever experienced . . . plus, we make some mean cocktails!

A Nags Head Restaurant Known for Food and Fun
Our food is fabulous, the atmosphere is pleasing and the drinks are good. But did you know that we’re also one of the most popular Nags Head restaurants for nightlife? We’re a well-known location for some of the area’s top bands and artists, ranging from hip hop to Reggae to our Sunday evening jazz dinners. With such a wide range of musical styles, we attract nightlife enthusiasts from young to old. Ours is a welcoming venue where you feel right at home if you’re 21 or 71!


New York Pizza Pub is offering both a $20 and a $35 Dinner Menu for Fall Restaurant Week 2018.


$20 Dinner Menu

  • 1st Course: Choice of One
    • Bruschette
    • Marinated Italian tomatoes, homemade crostinis, shredded parmesan cheese
    • Fried Calamari
    • Hand-breaded, served with homemade marinara sauce
    • Small Caesar Salad
    • Fresh, crispy romaine, tossed with croutons, grated Pecorino Romano, and Caesar dressing
    • Small Tossed Garden Salad
    • Fresh mixed lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, and onions
  • 2nd Course: Choice of one
    • Chicken Parmigiana
    • Hand-breaded chicken breast cutlet, smothered in mozzarella and marinara. Served with choice of pasta or baked potato and vegetable of the day
    • Penne Alla Vodka
    • Imported pasta covered with a homemade pink vodka sauce
    • Ravioli Parmigiana
    • Tender Ricotta cheese ravioli, smothered with mozzarella and marinara
    • Spaghetti and Meatballs
    • Spaghetti pasta combined with a homemade marinara sauce, topped with two Italian meatballs
    • Vegetable Pasta Primavera
    • Penne pasta, fresh vegetable medley, oil and garlic sauce
  • 3rd Course: Choice of One
    • Peanut Butter Pie
    • Key Lime Tart
    • NY Style Cheesecake
    • This is our version of perfect New York Style Cheesecake topped with peach or strawberry sauce

$35 Dinner Menu

  • 1st Course: Choice of One
    • Mixed Greens with Goat Cheese and Almonds
    • Fresh mixed greens, goat cheese, almonds, fresh vegetabels
    • Seared Tuna Bites
    • Served with homemade creamy balsamic
    • Shrimp Cocktail
    • Served with homemade cocktail sauce
  • 2nd Course: Choice of One
    • Seared Tuna
    • Local tuna steak, seared to the temperature of your choice, topped with a homemade mango relish. Served with choice pasta or baked potato and vegetable of the day
    • Lobster Alfredo
    • A NYPP favorite! Pink Alfredo sauce, fresh mushrooms, diced tomatoes, garlic and lobster over penne pasta
    • Chicken Marsala
    • Boneless chicken breast, homemade mushroom Marsala sauce. Served with choice of pasta or baked potato and vegetable of the day
    • Chargrilled Ribeye
    • 14 oz. hand cut Angus ribeye, topped with caramelized onions. Served with choice of pasta or baked potato and vegetable of the day
    • Osso Buco Pork
    • Braised pork shank, homemade mushroom bourbon sauce. Served with red skin mashed potatoes and vegetable of the day
  • 3rd Course: Choice of Dessert
    • Red Velvet Cake
    • Buttermilk, butter, cocoa
    • Sea Salt Caramel Gelato
    • NY Style Cheese Cake
    • This is our version of perfect New York Style Cheesecake, topped with peach or strawberry sauce
    • Tax and Gratuity are NOT included.

Get Directions